vol 11.16.26

A Letter to Timothy Snyder, History Professor, Yale University

Professor Snyder,

As a member of the august Yale faculty, I suspect your insular self-congratulatory world prevents you from receiving the repudiation of your work. I am writing to deliver that repudiation by quoting you.

In your own words, I will demonstrate to anyone who reads this column that you are easily unmasked as a supporter of the totalitarianism you try to denigrate. Moreover, I can easily show your arguments are poorly framed, specious, and writ large, damaging to your own country.

In your latest book titled, On Freedom, published in 2024, you write,

Donald Trump, Putin’s submissive client, is a hero of negative freedom, wealthy through undertaxed inheritance and comfortable denying everything.

In this single sentence you make three easily refuted assertions and expose yourself as an unabashed soldier of the left capable of promoting demonstrable falsehoods in the name of criminalizing your ideological opponent.
I’ll return to your sentence above but, for now, I will point to your assertion that he is the recipient of an undertaxed inheritance. Does anyone living and doing business in New York City believe he is undertaxed? Exactly how was that possible relative to the Trump money?

Later in the same paragraph you write,

When Trump lost the election, he lied about the outcome and tried to stage a coup d’ etat to stay in office.

He did not lie about the outcome. He challenged the validity of the vote count, as is his right, and as did Hillary Clinton regarding her loss, hundreds of times, does so to this day, as did Al Gore before her.

Secondly, how and when did Trump attempt a coup? I missed that. Are you accusing him of treason? What you leftists seem to forget is that when you accuse someone of a crime in a very public forum, a crime that you know he did not commit, your act is itself a crime.

This brings me back to your opening sentence quoted above where you label the current President of your country “Putin’s submissive client’ and assert that he is “comfortable denying everything.”

Of course, your use of the superlative, everything, is a gross misuse of the word. Is Trump guilty of denying that the earth orbits the sun? No, what you mean he is comfortable denying the multitudes of your insults and accusations, one of which is that he somehow colluded with the Russians to rig the 2016 election and to somehow steal it from Hillary Clinton.

In your assertion that he colluded with an enemy foreign power to change the outcome of a presidential election; you again publicly accuse him of a treasonous crime. During most of the four years of President Trump’s first term, 2016 to 2020, your accusation was the nightly lead story for the left-wing legacy media.

The television coverage featured a progressive pundit de jour or a Democrat politician such as Adam Schiff from California’s 28th Congressional District, who dutifully and continuously asserted that the evidence of Trump’s conspiracy with Russia was mounting and that "the walls are closing in” on the illegitimate stolen presidency.

During the same period, in May of 2017, then Acting Attorney General, Rod Rosenstein, appointed Robert Mueller, Special Counsel to investigate Trump and his Russian collusion in the 2016 presidential election.

Mueller’s team of 19 maximum-priced lawyers issued more than 2,800 subpoenas, executed nearly 500 search warrants and interviewed over 500 witnesses. Two years later, at a cost of $31 million, Mueller’s 400-page report concluded the president had not committed a crime.

Sadly, the investigation was itself an indictment of how authoritarian and oppressive our government can become. It led to the indictments of 37 individuals and entities, a handful of former Trump associates found guilty of campaign finance violations. (Given the enormity of the US Federal Register, rest assured, if a team of 19 lawyers mounted a two-year, $31 million-dollar probe of Yale’s fundraising practices, violations would be found.) As Stalin’s henchman so infamously said, “Show me the man and I’ll show you the crime.”

The Mueller probe was the perfect example of how totalitarianism is implemented.

Professor, while you pretend to champion freedom, you are a vicious advocate for totalitarian, oppressive government. You are the personification of why the leftist education establishment is now held in such low regard and why Jewish students feel unsafe on your elitist campuses.